FWD » Core Development » Conversion Tools

11/14/2022

03:05 PM Feature #6237: OEUnit support

Greg Shah wrote:
> We need to be able to specify the bootstrap configuration path/filename for a given test run.
... Vladimir Tsichevski

01:07 PM Feature #6237: OEUnit support

The latest diff @6237-215-14360.diff@. Vladimir Tsichevski

12:56 PM Feature #6237: OEUnit support

Vladimir Tsichevski wrote:
> We should add support for the classroot selector in the engine. This selector is not us... Vladimir Tsichevski

11:39 AM Feature #6237: OEUnit support

We should add support for the classroot selector in the engine. This selector is not used by Eclipse test launcher (E... Vladimir Tsichevski

11/11/2022

04:53 PM Feature #6237: OEUnit support

Greg Shah wrote:
> We need to be able to specify the bootstrap configuration path/filename for a given test run. Di... Vladimir Tsichevski

04:40 PM Feature #6237: OEUnit support

Greg Shah wrote:
> Unpack and rethrow it in the calling code on the client.
It works!
!6237-211.png! Vladimir Tsichevski

03:20 PM Feature #6237: OEUnit support

Unpack and rethrow it in the calling code on the client. Greg Shah

02:06 PM Feature #6237: OEUnit support

Vladimir Tsichevski wrote:
> My proposal is to follow the same way, and let the assertions library, implemented in... Vladimir Tsichevski

11/09/2022

07:46 AM Feature #6237: OEUnit support

We need to be able to specify the bootstrap configuration path/filename for a given test run. Different test runs in... Greg Shah

06:41 AM Feature #6237: OEUnit support

Greg Shah wrote:
> Some questions:
>
> * How do we register our test engine with these launchers?
> ** Eclipse
... Vladimir Tsichevski

06:12 AM Feature #6237: OEUnit support

Some questions:
* How do we register our test engine with these launchers?
** Eclipse
** ant
** gradle
** JUni... Greg Shah

11/08/2022

06:06 PM Feature #6237: OEUnit support

Greg Shah wrote:
> Are you saying there is absolutely no way to ever pass configuration from some launcher to our ... Vladimir Tsichevski

04:16 PM Feature #6237: OEUnit support

> There is no such thing as "direct JUnit invocation".
I'm talking about command line launching of JUnit.
> The... Greg Shah

04:07 PM Feature #6237: OEUnit support

Greg Shah wrote:
> From #6237-61 above:
>
> I want to reuse our existing approaches to configuration (e.g. using ... Vladimir Tsichevski

02:32 PM Feature #6237: OEUnit support

From #6237-61 above:
> Gather the necessary configuration (a @BootstrapConfig@ instance) to pass to the @ClientCor... Greg Shah

01:13 PM Feature #6237: OEUnit support

I see some potential problem: the test engine has no access to the command-line parameters, since these parameters ar... Vladimir Tsichevski

12:35 PM Feature #6237: OEUnit support

The problem with referencing Java class names in test suite Java sources resolved in @6237-200-14353.diff@.
Now th... Vladimir Tsichevski

07:38 PM Feature #6237: OEUnit support

> No, I do not propose using Java exceptions instead of legacy exceptions. Instead, at the server our test engine wil... Greg Shah

11/07/2022

06:17 PM Feature #6237: OEUnit support

Greg Shah wrote:
> Although I see the value in this idea, I wonder if using the JUnit exception instead of the legac... Vladimir Tsichevski

06:00 PM Feature #6237: OEUnit support

Although I see the value in this idea, I wonder if using the JUnit exception instead of the legacy exception will hav... Greg Shah

03:38 PM Feature #6237: OEUnit support

The expected legacy exception handling implemented both in conversion and runtime.
The diff is @6237-196-14352.diff@. Vladimir Tsichevski

03:34 PM Feature #6237: OEUnit support

JUnit5 Jupiter engine uses the @org.opentest4j@ package, namely the @AssertionFailedError@ from this package to store... Vladimir Tsichevski

02:33 PM Feature #6237: OEUnit support

Problem: if the test method throws a legacy exception, it is now returned to the client, but the legacy exception is ... Vladimir Tsichevski

11/02/2022

04:43 PM Feature #6237: OEUnit support

Vladimir Tsichevski wrote:
> In @ABLUnit@ it is valid to use instance methods (no static) as "before all" and "after... Vladimir Tsichevski

01:21 PM Feature #6237: OEUnit support

In @ABLUnit@ it is valid to use instance methods (no static) as "before all" and "after all" behavior. We need to add... Vladimir Tsichevski

11/01/2022

05:01 PM Feature #6237: OEUnit support

Greg Shah wrote:
> Please fix it in our conversion (generate only one annotation and merge the data).
This is fix... Vladimir Tsichevski

03:57 PM Bug #6901: Event handling - ON ANYWHERE

There are two issues with conversion of @ON@ statement in regards to @ANYWHERE@ option found during debugging of even... Marian Edu

03:57 PM Bug #6901 (Test): Event handling - ON ANYWHERE

Marian Edu

10/31/2022

10:01 AM Feature #6237: OEUnit support

Please fix it in our conversion (generate only one annotation and merge the data). Greg Shah

10/30/2022

04:51 PM Feature #6237: OEUnit support

4gl allows multiple annotations of the same type for the same element. This is used in some customer code to implemen... Vladimir Tsichevski

10/28/2022

05:07 PM Feature #6237: OEUnit support

Issues #6237-187 (automatic disabling the engine) and #6237-186 (@@TestSuite@ support) resolved in the patch @6237-18... Vladimir Tsichevski

10/27/2022

05:29 PM Feature #6237: OEUnit support

FWD test engine instantiation requires a connection to a FWD server. If this connection fails, the engine creation en... Vladimir Tsichevski

12:35 PM Support #6848: TRPL questions and issues

As the temporary workaround (just to continue the development), I can use the Java class names in the legacy 4gl sour... Vladimir Tsichevski

04:39 AM Support #6848: TRPL questions and issues

Constantin Asofiei wrote:
> Vladimir Tsichevski wrote:
> > Here I need to know the Java class names for legacy clas... Vladimir Tsichevski

10/26/2022

05:09 PM Support #6848: TRPL questions and issues

Vladimir Tsichevski wrote:
> Here I need to know the Java class names for legacy classes @unittests.SimpleTestOEUnit... Constantin Asofiei

04:20 PM Support #6848: TRPL questions and issues

Greg Shah wrote:
> Please just read the @pkgname@ and @classname@ annotations from the root node of the AST. You sh... Vladimir Tsichevski

02:35 PM Bug #6889: rollback the files as 'unconverted' if (incremental) conversion fails.

When incremental conversion is ran, once the parse phase finishes, a file is marked 'converted'. But, incremental co... Constantin Asofiei

02:34 PM Bug #6889 (Test): rollback the files as 'unconverted' if (incremental) conversion fails.

Constantin Asofiei

01:37 PM Feature #6237: OEUnit support

Vladimir Tsichevski wrote:
> @OEUnit@ supports dynamic test suites, for example:
>
> [...]
>
> I think, we wil... Vladimir Tsichevski

10/21/2022

04:12 PM Feature #6237: OEUnit support

For now, keep using the Java names. Greg Shah

12:57 PM Feature #6237: OEUnit support

Greg Shah wrote:
> Vladimir Tsichevski wrote:
> > Question: shall we use legacy names as display names or converted... Vladimir Tsichevski

12:49 PM Feature #6237: OEUnit support

Vladimir Tsichevski wrote:
> Question: shall we use legacy names as display names or converted Java class and method... Greg Shah

12:46 PM Feature #6237: OEUnit support

The updates in @6237-182-r14314.diff@:
# Legacy procedures-based tests support added: conversion and runtime.
# T... Vladimir Tsichevski

12:22 PM Feature #6237: OEUnit support

Question: shall we use legacy names as display names or converted Java class and method names? Vladimir Tsichevski

10/20/2022

10:24 AM Feature #6237: OEUnit support

Vladimir Tsichevski wrote:
> I think, the correct code is:
>
> [...]
Yes, the config needs to be marked 'persist... Constantin Asofiei

10:23 AM Feature #6237: OEUnit support

Vladimir Tsichevski wrote:
> Constantin Asofiei wrote:
> > Vladimir, what exactly are you trying to achieve? Gener... Constantin Asofiei

10:13 AM Feature #6237: OEUnit support

Constantin Asofiei wrote:
> For example: @new InvokeConfig(<program>).setProcedureHandle(h).run(arguments);@.
I... Vladimir Tsichevski

09:00 AM Feature #6237: OEUnit support

Constantin Asofiei wrote:
> Vladimir, what exactly are you trying to achieve? Generate Java code? Write Java code b... Vladimir Tsichevski

06:35 AM Feature #6237: OEUnit support

Vladimir, what exactly are you trying to achieve? Generate Java code? Write Java code by hand?
Direct usage of @C... Constantin Asofiei

10/19/2022

05:40 PM Feature #6237: OEUnit support

I am implementing the procedure-based unit tests for @ABLUnit@, and I do not know the proper way to create procedure ... Vladimir Tsichevski

05:13 PM Feature #6237: OEUnit support

Unlike JUnit5, @OEUnit@ uses a single instance to run all instance-related test methods in the class (JUnit5 by defau... Vladimir Tsichevski

08:50 AM Feature #6237: OEUnit support

Issues #6237-156, #6237-163 and #6237-170 now fixed in @6237-173-r14306.diff@. The diff is against the FWD rev. 14306. Vladimir Tsichevski

08:35 AM Feature #6237: OEUnit support

Greg Shah wrote:
> > The first method is not possible, since there is no such place in the custom test engine code, ... Vladimir Tsichevski

08:00 AM Feature #6237: OEUnit support

> The first method is not possible, since there is no such place in the custom test engine code, where all root test ... Greg Shah

07:54 AM Support #6848: TRPL questions and issues

Please just read the @pkgname@ and @classname@ annotations from the root node of the AST. You should not be converti... Greg Shah

10/18/2022

05:14 PM Feature #6237: OEUnit support

Another problem to solve related to test method discovery:
# the user requests running a Java package as JUnit Tes... Vladimir Tsichevski

04:18 PM Support #6848: TRPL questions and issues

I need to convert legacy class names to converted Java class name (simple names and FQN). Which library method should... Vladimir Tsichevski

11:34 AM Support #6848: TRPL questions and issues

> I need to either find the place in the code, in which the prog.symbol can be converted to java symbol and fix it
... Greg Shah

11:32 AM Support #6848: TRPL questions and issues

Greg Shah wrote:
> The @SYMBOL@ you are referencing may be the @prog.symbol@ type. Notice this is in the @prog@ (fo... Vladimir Tsichevski

10:49 AM Support #6848: TRPL questions and issues

The @SYMBOL@ you are referencing may be the @prog.symbol@ type. Notice this is in the @prog@ (for @Progress@) namesp... Greg Shah

10:05 AM Support #6848: TRPL questions and issues

Greg Shah wrote:
> We wouldn't get very far in conversion if we couldn't emit symbols or data types. The authoritat... Vladimir Tsichevski

10/17/2022

07:22 PM Support #6848: TRPL questions and issues

We wouldn't get very far in conversion if we couldn't emit symbols or data types. The authoritative source of how Ja... Greg Shah

07:07 PM Support #6848: TRPL questions and issues

I need to create a Java annotation of the following type:... Vladimir Tsichevski

06:15 PM Support #6848: TRPL questions and issues

@dbref/collect_refs.xml@ is currently disabled code and was left there on purpose. It is intended to identify refere... Greg Shah

04:28 PM Support #6848: TRPL questions and issues

About the legacy annotation attribute values.
Annotations containing attributes can look like this:... Vladimir Tsichevski

03:57 PM Support #6848: TRPL questions and issues

I found, that to convert a Java array to @java.util.List@, the @createListFromObject@ library function can be used.
... Vladimir Tsichevski

03:29 PM Support #6848: TRPL questions and issues

Questions about the TRPL language should be posted and discussed here. Vladimir Tsichevski

03:27 PM Support #6848 (New): TRPL questions and issues

Vladimir Tsichevski

08:16 AM Feature #6237: OEUnit support

Greg Shah wrote:
> Think about it and try to estimate the changes that are needed.
OK Vladimir Tsichevski

07:52 AM Feature #6237: OEUnit support

Think about it and try to estimate the changes that are needed. Greg Shah

07:46 AM Feature #6237: OEUnit support

Greg Shah wrote:
> > We will need to support dynamic tests then: the tests which are created in runtime by executing... Vladimir Tsichevski

07:20 AM Feature #6237: OEUnit support

> We will need to support dynamic tests then: the tests which are created in runtime by executing customer 4gl code. ... Greg Shah

07:12 AM Feature #6237: OEUnit support

Greg Shah wrote:
> Vladimir Tsichevski wrote:
> > Greg Shah wrote:
> > > > I think, we will not support these, ins... Vladimir Tsichevski

07:05 AM Feature #6237: OEUnit support

Vladimir Tsichevski wrote:
> Greg Shah wrote:
> > > I think, we will not support these, instead the declarative app... Greg Shah